I grew up as a rebellious child. At school, I was the obedient one, but at home, the situation was quite different. My parents found it hard to believe when my teachers praised me for being responsible and reliable. I often wonder where the origins of my rebellion lie, as I began challenging the status quo at a very young age—around 3 or 4 years old.
To this day, I continue to assert myself, often questioning and subtly influencing changes within my family or their mindset. I believe my desire to carve out my own identity, distinct from that of my family, played a crucial role in shaping my rebellious nature. While I was once considered the misbehaved one, my family now approaches me with patience and understanding, striving to comprehend my perspective. If any of this resonates with you, I encourage you to stop feeling guilty or ashamed. Let’s explore the factors that contribute to becoming a rebel, why you might identify as one, and, most importantly, why you should embrace and be grateful for it.
The Role Of Rebellion In Identity Formation
Erik Erikson’s fourth stage of Psychosocial Development is that of Identity vs Confusion. This stage occurs during adolescence between the ages of approximately 12 and 18. During this stage, adolescents explore their independence and develop a sense of self.
Erikson defines identity as a “fundamental organizing principal which develops constantly throughout the lifespan.” Identity involves the experiences, relationships, beliefs, values, and memories that make up a person’s subjective sense of self. This helps create a continuous self-image that remains fairly constant even as new aspects of the self are developed or strengthened over time.
In the transitional period from children to adults, teens often find themselves confused about how they fit in society. They will throw fits at home, not conform to rules at school, and might experiment with impulsive behaviours in public such as rash driving, using substances, etc. Some try to take on roles and responsibilities. These are all subconscious ways of figuring out what resonates the most with them. According to Erikson, this is important to the process of forming a strong identity and developing a sense of direction in life.
Carving Our Own Path
It can be difficult for our loved ones to see us being rebellious and carving our own path through trial and error. Anything different from someone else’s perceived ‘normal’ way of living life is bound to invite criticism. But this is our first life. We are allowed to make mistakes, learn from them, adapt to the ever evolving world, and get closer to who we truly are.
By pushing against the status quo, we are able to assert autonomy and balance it with conformity. We also start getting passionate about social causes and take up several hobbies. Teens and young adults want to make their own decisions, and when parents question those choices, it can feel like an attack that leads to an explosive response. Sometimes what we are looking for as a teen space which parents may confuse for rebellion.
Search For Meaning
At its core, rebellion often stems from a dissatisfaction with superficial or materialistic societal goals, which can feel meaningless. In rejecting societal pressures to conform to a pre-defined notion of success, young people are often asking a fundamental question: What truly matters to me? This search for deeper meaning—whether through questioning authority, engaging in activism, or exploring alternative lifestyles—can lead individuals to discover their own sense of purpose. Rebellion, then, becomes a form of seeking higher ideals that resonate more deeply with one’s internal sense of fulfillment.
What’s So Great About It?
Rebelliousness during this time often forces individuals to reflect deeply on who they are and what they want out of life. By pushing against boundaries, people explore their own beliefs, desires, and values.
During rebellious phases, people often face challenges—whether in the form of strained relationships, failure, or social judgment. Navigating these struggles helps build resilience. Learning to cope with the consequences of one’s actions and finding solutions to difficult problems fosters emotional strength and adaptability. This resilience, born out of adversity, becomes a lifelong asset, making future challenges easier to handle.
When individuals break away from conventional paths, they are free to think outside the box, pursue unconventional ideas, and take creative risks. Whether it’s artistic expression, entrepreneurship, or innovative ways of living, these rebellious years provide a fertile ground for creative experimentation.
By rejecting social masks and challenging groupthink, individuals attract like-minded friends who share similar values. These authentic relationships, built on mutual understanding and shared ideals, are often deeper and more meaningful than those formed through superficial conformity.
This period of rebellion can be seen as a rite of passage into adulthood. It is a necessary stage in the journey toward maturity. Without it, individuals may never fully understand their own capacity for choice, consequence, and self-direction.
What Happens When Your Identity Isn’t Fully Formed
- Difficulties with commitment: A stable personal identity allows individuals to have better relationships with others.
- Worse mental health and well-being: Research has linked a strong sense of identity to better emotional and psychological well-being in adolescents.
- Weak sense of self: Role confusion has been found to lead to a weak sense of self.
- Lack of confidence: A lack of self-identity can make it difficult for people to have confidence in themselves and their abilities.
How To Shun The Shame
Feeling shame or guilt about past rebelliousness is common, especially when reflecting on decisions that may have caused conflict or led to mistakes. However, it’s important to shift the perspective from self-criticism to self-compassion and recognize the growth that comes from these experiences.
- Reframe – Instead of seeing your rebellious behavior as a negative or shameful aspect of your past, reframe it as an important step in your journey toward self-discovery. Everyone goes through periods of growth, and rebellion is often a necessary part of it.
- Lessons Learned – Whether it’s understanding your values more clearly, learning how to navigate conflict, or realizing the consequences of certain actions, these experiences have shaped who you are today. By acknowledging the personal growth and wisdom gained, you can feel more at peace with your past rebelliousness.
- Self-Compassion – Self-compassion involves being kind to yourself, especially when reflecting on your flaws or mistakes. Instead of being harsh or judgmental, treat yourself with the same empathy you would offer a friend. Understand that everyone makes mistakes, and rebellion is often a way of seeking autonomy or purpose in a complex world.
- Acknowledge Influence – Sometimes feelings of shame or guilt stem from cultural or family expectations that discourage rebellion. If you grew up in an environment where obedience and conformity were highly valued, it’s natural to feel shame when you went against the grain.
- Personal Accountability – It’s important to differentiate between healthy accountability and unhealthy shame. Taking responsibility for any harm caused by your rebellious actions is crucial. Make amends where necessary, but also give yourself permission to move forward.
- Mindfulness – Guilt and shame often arise when we ruminate on things we can’t change. By practicing mindfulness, you can learn to accept the past without judgment and focus on the present moment.
While it may lead to moments of conflict, mistakes, or regret, it also serves as a powerful tool for asserting independence, challenging societal norms, and exploring who we truly are. I hope reading this piece was even a little cathartic for you. Rebellion often leads to deeper connections with ourselves and others, as well as a clearer sense of purpose. Ultimately, rebellion is not something to feel ashamed of but rather a phase to appreciate for the insights and strength it brings, allowing us to pursue a life of greater fulfillment and authenticity.
If you’re looking for counselling or psychotherapy, please book a session using our online calendar.
